Willamette Valley

Refuge may allow elk hunting


Half a century ago, when the William L. Finley National Wildlife Refuge south of Corvallis was established to protect migratory waterfowl, sightings of Roosevelt elk were a rare occurrence in the Willamette Valley.
In recent years, however, the majestic animals have made quite a comeback on the valley floor. In the last decade, the Oregon Department of Fish & Wildlife estimates, the population has mushroomed from 100 to at least 600 individuals.
The biggest herd in the region makes its home on the Finley Wildlife Refuge, where an estimated 200-plus elk have become a major draw for visitors — and a growing problem for neighboring landowners.
State and federal wildlife managers say the animals cause extensive damage when they periodically wander off the 6,000-acre refuge, eating or trampling crops and knocking down fences that stand in their way.
Now, to reduce the damage, ODFW and Finley biologists are floating a plan to reduce the herd by opening the refuge to elk hunting for the first time.
If approved by the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service, the plan would allow a three-month hunting season for antlerless elk (cows and “spikes,” or yearling bulls) in the late summer and early fall.
Five permits would be issued to Willamette Valley elk tag holders each month from August through October for a total take of up to 15 elk, and only bowhunting would be allowed the first year.
“We have a goal to reduce the size of the elk herd by 20 percent over five years,” said Jock Beall, the refuge biologist at Finley.
The plan is being welcomed by most area farmers and duck-hunting clubs, which plant corn to attract waterfowl.
But the idea is not without controversy. A large number of Finley’s 100,000 annual visitors come to the refuge to watch or photograph wildlife. To them, the elk are rock stars.
“Elk are a charismatic species,” Beall acknowledged. “(Visitors) like them and they like the viewing, and they think (the hunt) will change the opportunity or decrease the opportunity to view them.”
You can count Ricardo Small among that group.
A retired Arizona real estate appraiser who now spends most of the year in the mid-valley, he’s a regular at Finley. From his perspective, any damage the elk may be doing on private property shouldn’t be the refuge’s problem.
“The elk are a major magnet for visitors, and there is no information I can find in any Fish & Wildlife report to indicate the elk are doing any damage to resources on the refuge,” Small pointed out.
“My position is there’s no reason to open up the refuge to elk hunting. Let them open up their land to hunting — but I guess that’s not palatable to the private landowners.”
As recently as 1989, there were only about 20 elk on the Finley National Wildlife Refuge. A decade later the tally had jumped to 100, and last year the Finley herd numbered 163 animals.
A second herd of 38 elk has taken up residence since then, according to Beall, and there’s another group of 10 to 15 bachelor bulls that hangs around the fringes of the two established herds.
There’s plenty of forage and tree cover on the refuge, and because hunting currently is not allowed at Finley, it provides a safe haven for the animals during the valley elk season, which runs from August through March.
It’s good habitat for Roosevelt elk, the largest North American subspecies, which can weigh in at half a ton and stand 5 feet tall at the shoulder. In fact, the biggest Roosevelt bull on record was taken just south of the refuge boundary in 2002. The taxidermied trophy is now on display at Cabela’s sporting goods store in Springfield.
Even though the refuge proposal would not allow hunting of mature bulls (which tend to be targeted by off-refuge hunters and are underrepresented in the Finley herd), some wildlife lovers fear any hunting would make Finley’s elk skittish.
“I oppose the plan mainly because of what it would do to the recreational aspect — viewing elk on the refuge,” said Phil Hays, another refuge regular, in an email to the Gazette-Times.
“The (environmental assessment) specifically states that hunting causes elk to remain hidden during the day, and they come out to feed at night,” he added. “The refuge is open dawn to dusk. Seems to me that hunting will make the already elusive herd less visible to visitors at the refuge.”
ODFW biologist Steven Marx, who served as a consultant on the management proposal, says he can undrestand that point of view. But he added that his agency has a responsibility to do something about the “chronic damage” caused by elk in the area.
“A lot of times it’s difficult to appreciate the problem until it’s on your property,” Marx said.
“The goal is not to eliminate the elk, it’s to manage them at a level compatible with local land use.”
Finley already takes criticism from farmers who suffer crop damage from the thousands of migrating Canada geese that winter in the Willamette Valley, roosting on refuge ponds by night and hammering nearby grass seed fields by day.
The rapidly growing elk population is quickly becoming another sore point for neighboring landowners, and refuge managers see the hunting proposal in part as a way to show they care and are willing to take steps to keep the problem from growing worse.
“Part of it is to show we are trying to be responsive,” Beall said.
“(And) some of it is meant to be preventative — so we don’t wait to see how much damage there will be if we have 300 elk.”
Contact reporter Bennett Hall at [email protected] or 541-758-9529.

Oregon Department of Transportation considers constructing a high-speed railway from Eugene to Portland


The Oregon Department of Transportation (ODOT) is in the process of planning and evaluating the construction of a high-speed railway from the Eugene-Springfield area to Portland. Last night, ODOT held an open house at the Eugene Public Library. Members of the public attended to gain more knowledge and state their input on the project. According […]

Wine Down Eugene


I love Oregon Pinot Noir. Its diverse terroir driven characteristics and fresh, pure berry and earthy deliciousness; combined with, unmatched complexity, depth and elegance, enable each wine and vintage to be individually exciting, exclusive and unique.

Wine Down Eugene


I'm feeling like a very happy wine gal these days; blue skies, warm air, and a summer full of stellar wine events and media trips throughout Oregon and Washington - life couldn't be better. There is much to look forward to, much to be excited about, and a whole lot to write about.

Wine Down Eugene: 100th Edition!


Wow, this is the 100th issue of Wine Down Eugene! For a total of 100 weeks, I've been bringing the readers of Eugene Daily News a weekly listing of wine related happenings and events at local shops, restaurants, bars and wineries.

Domaine Meriwether’s Inaugural Fine Dining in the Cellar


I must admit, I really love my job. Who wouldn't love attending fabulous food and wine events around the state of Oregon? Like I've said before, I'm a lucky wine gal, and I never take that for granted.

Banning GMO’s: The New Civil Rights Movement


As the fight over genetically modified canola and other GM crops escalates in the Willamette Valley, a group of farmers and neighbors in Benton County have spent the past year talking about how to stop GMO’s. They’ve asked the question that people across the country ask when faced with corporate threats – such as GMO’s, fracking, or water privatization – how do we say no?

Wine Down Eugene


"Fire up that grill, honey!" I've said those exact words on numerous occasions since the clouds have dispersed and the sun has been shining down on the Willamette Valley; indeed, I love to cook in the great outdoors - one of the many reasons why I love summer.

0 $0.00