Is He Right Or Wrong This Year? And Does It Really Matter?

Marmota Monax (Groundhog) | Photo by discover

The skiers have been loving it, but for valley residents this has been a pretty bad Winter so far. We had an ice storm in December to end 2016 and another one with snow and then ice in the month of January to begin 2017. Trees, power lines, homes and even vehicles suffered damage from the weight of the ice. Many of us were without electricity during one or both of the storms. The most stressful thing to me is that Winter isn’t anywhere near being over yet. There is still plenty of time for us to see freezing rain, sleet and snow that can greatly complicate our lives. We had some icy streets Friday February 3rd, but not a major ice storm. During a storm just to our north on Sunday February 5th they saw snow in Seattle.

There is one event that can put a smile on the face of even the grumpiest Winter storm hater and that takes place just once a year. As a matter of fact it was just this past week. That is Groundhog Day. Somehow watching this furry critter being held up and revered as a weather prognosticator brings a smile and often a laugh to most of us. I’m not sure everyone knows how it all got started so I decided to use this column to give you the detailed information.

According to my old standby Wikipedia “Groundhog Day (Canadian French: Jour de la Marmot; Pennsylvania German: Grundsaudaag, Murmeltiertag) is a traditional holiday originating in the United States that is celebrated on February 2. According to folklore, if it is cloudy when a groundhog emerges from its burrow on this day, then the spring season will arrive early, sometime before the the vernal equinox; if it is sunny, the groundhog will supposedly see its shadow and retreat back into its den, and winter weather will persist for six more weeks.”

The definition only explains what Groundhog Day is, but not how it started. I’ll rely on for the origin of this celebration. Apparently the idea started with Candlemas Day which is an ancient Christian tradition in which candles that were blessed by the clergy were given to the people representing the length and severity of the winter to come. It seems the Germans ran with that idea adding a hedgehog as the critter that would actually predict the severity and length or lack of same the rest of the winter season.

What about how the event came to America? says “Once they came to America, German settlers in Pennsylvania continued the tradition, although they switched from hedgehogs to groundhogs, which were plentiful in the Keystone State.”

Marmota Monax (Groundhog) | Photo by discover

Marmota monax is the scientific name for the groundhog which is often called a woodchuck. Here is when the celebration began. Again “In 1887, a newspaper editor belonging to a group of groundhog hunters from Punxsutawney called the Punxsutawney Groundhog Club declared that Phil, the Punxsutawney groundhog, was America’s only true weather-forecasting groundhog. The line of groundhogs that have since been known as Phil might be America’s most famous groundhogs, but other towns across North America now have their own weather-forecasting rodents, from Birmingham Bill to Staten Island Chuck to Shubenacdie Sam in Canada.”

Now that you have the background information it’s time for my annual Groundhog Report. I usually post this as a short report separate from my column, but this time I will expand on it and add as many varied groundhog reports as I can find.

Punxsutawney Phil | Photo by

Let’s start with Punxsutawney Phil who this year is reported to have seen his shadow predicting six more weeks of winter. Here is his official web page. Two things come into question here. First, with all of the lights for the television cameras how could he not see his shadow and secondly the actual decision is made the night before by a specially designated group of people. Also Phil’s been wrong before.


General Lee
General Beauregard Lee Atlanta, GA | Photo by Georgia Tech News

General Beauregard Lee from Atlanta, Georgia did not see his shadow meaning an early spring is on the way. His web official web page is

Malverne Mel
Photo by Rosanno Weitecamp

Next we check out Malvern Mel from Long Island, New York. Nearly 300 people gathered at Reese Park to witness Mel’s prediction of an early spring since he did not see his shadow.

Holtsville Hal
Holtsville Hal | Image by News !2 Long Island

Holtsville Hal did see his shadow in Brooklyn, New York predicting 6 more weeks of winter.

Now on to Staten Island Chuck, from where else but Staten Island, New York, predicted an early spring due to the fact that he did not see his shadow.

For some unknown reason New York State has a plethora of groundhogs. Dunkirk Dave from Dunkirk, New York did see his shadow so he joins in with the long winter crowd.

Buckeye Chuck
Buckeye Chuck | Photo by the Rempe Family through A & HT

Next in line is Buckeye Chuck resides in Marion, Ohio and at 7:40 a.m. February 2nd he did see his shadow predicting 6 more weeks of winter.

Sir Walter Wally resides in Raleigh, North Carolina did not see his shadow so he predicts an early spring.

We have two foreign groundhog reports. The one that I have used for many years is Wiarton Willie from Ontario, Canada. Willie did not see his shadow predicting an early spring. The other Canadian groundhog is Shubenacadie Sam from Nova Scotia and he didn’t see his shadow either keeping with the early spring prediction.

Now we come to the last, and for us the most important groundhog, Spencer Butte Bob who is my personal prognosticator. Bob did not see his shadow so that puts him in the category of predicting an early spring.

Spencer Butte Bob, The South Hills Groundhog | Photo by Tim Chuey

Now that we have heard from a large group of groundhogs let’s tally up the two sides. We have ten reports and the split with 6 predicting an early spring and 4 predicting 6 more weeks of winter. If you flip a coin the odds of getting heads or correctly predicting the weather for the next 6 weeks are the same. Personally if these predictions really mean anything I’d pick Spencer Butte Bob’s prediction of an early spring because he is here in Eugene, Oregon’s South Hills.

Let me know what you would like me to talk about or explain. You can comment below or email me at: [email protected].

Tim Chuey is a Member of the American Meteorological Society and the National Weather Association and has been Awarded Seals of Approval for television weathercasting from both organizations.

Previous Story

Deommodore Lenoir, nation's No. 1 athlete, commits to Oregon Ducks –

Next Story

Josh Falo, nation's No. 2 TE, commits to USC Trojans over Oregon Ducks –

Latest from Columns

Here We Go Again!

The Extreme Drought conditions we are experiencing in Oregon have severely increased the danger of wildfires.